When the Cup Overflows: Why We Need to Talk About Suicide Before It’s Too Late
Suicide is a heavy subject—so heavy that we often avoid it until it’s too late. When someone says they’re overwhelmed, sad, or at the end of their rope, our first reactions are often meant to comfort but end up minimizing: “You’ll be OK,” “People have it worse,” or spiritual lines like “God doesn’t give you more than you can bear.” We say these things because we want to help someone “snap out” of it. But those phrases can leave the person feeling unseen, alone, and more convinced that no one understands how full their cup already is.
The cup metaphor: when sadness becomes capacity
Think of a cup filling up. Early on, people share loneliness, frustration, or exhaustion — the cup is rising and they reach out. But there’s a point where the cup nears overflow: the crying, the hopeless talk, the withdrawal, the repeated “It’s too much.” When someone is considering suicide, they’ve often reached that overflow point. This isn’t about optimism vs. pessimism — it’s about capacity. The load has become unbearable.
Why we avoid the conversation
We dodge these moments for a few reasons:
Sadness feels contagious. When someone vulnerably expresses pain, it pokes at our own wounds and discomfort.
We don’t know what to say, so we default to platitudes or judgment.
Fear and misunderstanding make suicide taboo; people imagine it's a “weak” choice instead of recognizing the crushing power of prolonged pain.
When we respond with judgment (“What’s wrong with them?” or “They need to get over it”), we’re often projecting our own fear and shame. That response shuts down the very connection the person needs.
Suicide isn’t weakness
Suicide is not a weak-person solution. It’s what can happen when someone has carried unbearable weight for so long that they want the suffering to stop. It’s the point where the crying ceases and they can’t see air. Seeing suicide this way calls for compassion, not condemnation.
What we can do — notice, reach out, and help unpack the bag
If we want fewer deaths by suicide, we must normalize noticing the signs and acting early. When you see someone’s energy change, when they say “it’s too much,” when their posts or behavior show ongoing struggle—reach out.
Concrete ways to help:
Listen first. Let them talk without interrupting or minimizing. You don’t need to “fix” it—being present matters.
Ask directly. It’s okay to ask, “Are you thinking about killing yourself?” Asking won’t put the idea in their head; it gives them permission to be honest.
Validate feelings. Say things like, “That sounds incredibly hard,” instead of “You’ll get over it.”
Offer practical support. Help find a therapist, make a call with them, sit with them while they make an appointment, or help remove immediate means of harm if safe to do so.
Don’t leave them alone if they’re in immediate danger. Call local emergency services or a crisis line for guidance.
Follow up. One conversation isn’t enough. Keep checking in — consistent care matters.
If someone is in crisis
In the U.S.: call or text 988, or use the chat at 988lifeline.org to get immediate support.
If you’re outside the U.S., contact your local emergency number or local crisis services.
If someone is in immediate danger, call emergency services and stay with them if it’s safe.
A call to normalize early care
Let’s normalize the work of helping people unpack their bag before it’s too late. Notice changes. Ask the hard questions. Offer presence and help find professional support. Regret after a loss shows us how powerful pain can be—and how much our small, steady acts of compassion and attention can matter.
If you’re reading this and you’re hurting: you are not alone, you don’t have to carry it on your own, and help is available. If you’re worried about someone, reach out—your presence could be the moment their cup stops overflowing.
If you found value in this message,
share it with someone you think needs to hear this,
and Subscribe to the Ready Counseling Newsletter for more!